Government must end crazy ID cards plan now, says Assembly Member

12.00.00am GMT Thu 22nd Nov 2007

Peter being interviewed (photography: Peter Black)

The Government's data disaster over child benefit records shows why plans for Identity Cards must be scrapped, according to Welsh Liberal Democrat Assembly Member, Peter Black.

Following the revelation that the personal details of 25 million parents and children have been lost by the Government's Revenue and Customs department (HMRC), and may have fallen into the hands of identity fraudsters, Mr. Black says that the Prime Minister should abandon his plans for a national ID cards scheme and a National Identity Register in which the Government want to store the personal information of everyone in the country.

"The fiasco at HMRC has shown the dangers of the Government holding huge amounts of information about each one of us whilst being slipshod in the way that same information is looked after," said Mr. Black.

"This whole saga of incompetence has been shocking and families in Swansea, Neath Port Talbot and Bridgend are now rightly asking whether their personal details are safe.

"The National Identity Register, which the Government are setting up as part of the Identity Card scheme, will hold vastly more information on each and every one of us than Customs and Revenue managed to lose.

"The possibilities for the loss of that information, either accidentally or through illegitimate means must make the Government stop and think again very seriously about their plan to store all the data they can on us on a central register.

"This is a clear illustration of the real dangers of a big brother centralised state. State control of personal identity details is a real threat to our civil liberties. The Government should respond to the anger and now abandon its ID card scheme. It is clear that the Government cannot be trusted to manage effectively mass databases of personal information.

"The Liberal Democrats opposed Identity Cards when the scheme went through Parliament. We said the scheme would be expensive, misguided and insecure. This latest debacle shows just what is at risk.

"That is why Gordon Brown should think again. The Government must end the Identity Card scheme for good in order to ensure that we do not risk a personal data disaster on an even more catastrophic scale."

Bookmark this story at: del.icio.us Digg Facebook reddit StumbleUpon
Print this news story.
Comment on this news story.
Previous news story: Assembly Member calls for steps to end Fuel Poverty (Wed 21st Nov 2007).
Next news story: Assembly Member calls for transparency on local government reform (Fri 23rd Nov 2007).

Related News Stories:

Tue 14th Oct 2008:

Council must consult on closure of Troed-y-Ton says Assembly Member.

Parliament should not dictate housing policy to Wales says Assembly Member.

Mon 22nd Sep 2008:

Assembly Member demands action on pre-paid energy meters.

Fri 19th Sep 2008:

Sneaky price hike by airlines will reduce passenger protection says Assembly Member.

Thu 18th Sep 2008:

Labour is attempting to build a surveillance society by stealth says Assembly Member.

Fri 29th Aug 2008:

Police crime maps will create more problems than they solve says Assembly Member.

Thu 28th Aug 2008:

Assembly Member seeks assurances on Singleton Hospital casualty unit.

Thu 21st Aug 2008:

Local Authorities need power and funding to break mortgage deadlock says Assembly Member.

Sun 10th Aug 2008:

Video Game Classification needs reform to protect children says Assembly Member.

Thu 7th Aug 2008:

More blogging politicians needed says Assembly Member.

Tue 5th Aug 2008:

Post Office reprieve welcome for two communities, disaster for thirty three says Assembly Member .

Tue 22nd Jul 2008:

Assembly Member congratulates Crusaders on Super League Spot.

Tue 15th Jul 2008:

Time for water companies to cough up says Assembly Member.

Sat 12th Jul 2008:

Closure of phone boxes will leave vulnerable stranded says Assembly Member.

Fri 4th Jul 2008:

Assembly Member backs Cork Ferry campaign.

Sat 28th Jun 2008:

Tenants of Buy to let mortgage lenders must have more protection says Assembly Member.

Thu 26th Jun 2008:

Assembly Member welcomes drop in road casualties.

Thu 12th Jun 2008:

Assembly Member concerned by drop off in house building.

Sat 7th Jun 2008:

Assembly Member backs Carers' Week.

Thu 5th Jun 2008:

Assembly Member shocked by 183.2% credit offer .

Mon 2nd Jun 2008:

Assembly Member vows to fight Post Office Closures.

Fri 23rd May 2008:

Help the Aged report's conclusions 'shame our society' says Assembly Member.

Age Concern report's conclusions 'shame our society' says Assembly Member.

Thu 22nd May 2008:

Assembly Member consults schools on Foundation Phase funding.

Wed 14th May 2008:

Assembly Member congratulates Swansea on transport award.

Fri 9th May 2008:

Cost cutting on ID cards will undermine security says Assembly Member.

Sun 20th Apr 2008:

'Sale and rent aid on homes is too little, too late' says Assembly Member.

Thu 17th Apr 2008:

Assembly Member expresses concern at changes to rural ambulance support.

Wed 16th Apr 2008:

Assembly Member does historic double in private member ballots.

Tue 15th Apr 2008:

Assembly Member offers support to Bridgend Post Office threatened by rent review.

Tue 8th Apr 2008:

Assembly Member quizzes First Minister on child poverty stats.

Tue 18th Mar 2008:

Assembly Member calls for action on anti-social behaviour in Morriston playing fields.

Wed 12th Mar 2008:

Assembly Member sets the pace with first Green Dragon Award for an elected representative.

Tue 11th Mar 2008:

Assembly Member rallies colleagues behind Grand Slam bid.

Fri 7th Mar 2008:

Assembly Member backs campaign for reform government call centres.

Wed 5th Mar 2008:

Assembly Member reveals true gap in social housing.

Fri 29th Feb 2008:

Assembly Member hits out at Revenue and Customs job cuts.

Assembly Member welcomes Small Shops Bill.

Thu 28th Feb 2008:

Assembly Member requests funding for local Counselling Services.

Fri 22nd Feb 2008:

Unfreeze Winter Fuel Payment demands Assembly Member.

Thu 21st Feb 2008:

British Gas profits underline case for regulation says Assembly Member.

Mon 18th Feb 2008:

Excess winter deaths in Wales a badge of shame says Assembly Member.

Wed 30th Jan 2008:

Assembly Member welcomes Nick Clegg to Ospreylia.

Tue 22nd Jan 2008:

Assembly Member disagrees on digital.

Wed 16th Jan 2008:

Assembly Member welcomes review of mobile phone deals.

Sat 5th Jan 2008:

Assembly Member expresses outrage at fuel price rise.

Thu 3rd Jan 2008:

Focus on education to help combat poverty says Assembly Member.

Tue 18th Dec 2007:

Local Assembly Member congratulates new Liberal Democrat leader.

Mon 3rd Dec 2007:

Assembly Member calls for action to protect public from government data failures.

Tue 27th Nov 2007:

Assembly Member calls for action to protect children from the dangers of the internet.

Fri 23rd Nov 2007:

Assembly Member calls for transparency on local government reform.

Wed 21st Nov 2007:

Assembly Member calls for steps to end Fuel Poverty.

Tue 20th Nov 2007:

Assembly Member supports 'Hungry to be Heard' campaign.

Thu 15th Nov 2007:

Assembly Member puts pressure on train companies to improve.

Tue 23rd Oct 2007:

More support needed for community pharmacies says Assembly Member.

Assembly Member demands fairer fares for Maesteg.

Mon 15th Oct 2007:

Assembly Member pledges support for Carbon Monoxide poisoning awareness.

Tue 9th Oct 2007:

Assembly Member says Government cannot escape blame for tax credit debacle.

Mon 8th Oct 2007:

Assembly Member calls for urgent action to counter homeless figures.

Mon 1st Oct 2007:

Assembly Member supports student campaigns.

Wed 26th Sep 2007:

Assembly Member criticises decision to prosecute 'gypsy site' petitioner .

Mon 24th Sep 2007:

Assembly Member congratulates Student Union on tidy-up campaign.

Wed 12th Sep 2007:

Post Office closures hit poorer urban areas worse says Assembly Member.

Mon 10th Sep 2007:

Child Trust Fund should be scrapped says assembly member.

Wed 5th Sep 2007:

Judge wrong on DNA database says Assembly Member.

Wed 29th Aug 2007:

Credit Card companies continue to hit customers with high charges says Assembly Member.

Tue 28th Aug 2007:

Assembly Member seeks to define what the Welsh Liberal Democrats are for.

Wed 22nd Aug 2007:

Local Assembly Member welcomes new jobs for Swansea.

Mon 20th Aug 2007:

Assembly Member urges rethink on job losses.

Tue 7th Aug 2007:

Banks continue to overcharge customers says Assembly Member.

Tue 31st Jul 2007:

Assembly Member calls for better pay for Coastguards.

Thu 26th Jul 2007:

More rail fare rises are on the horizon says Assembly Member.

Tue 17th Jul 2007:

South Wales Assembly Member urges rethink on job losses.

Thu 12th Jul 2007:

Child Support Agency replacement 'not fit for purpose' says Assembly Member.

Wed 4th Jul 2007:

Assembly Member urges rethink on Swansea Prison drug rehabilitation wing.

Tue 3rd Jul 2007:

Indecision on neurosurgery will prolong the agony says Assembly Member.

Sun 1st Jul 2007:

New legislation is needed to protect workers' right to use Welsh says Assembly Member.

Wed 13th Jun 2007:

Assembly Member objects to development at Bryncoch Farm .

Wed 23rd May 2007:

High-street banks must stop ripping charities off says Assembly Member.

Tue 22nd May 2007:

Assembly Member seeks talks on Remploy factory closure.

Wed 4th Apr 2007:

There must be no postcode lottery on postal charges says Assembly Member.

Sat 31st Mar 2007:

Assembly Member urges Visteon to reconsider job losses.

Mon 26th Mar 2007:

Proper monitoring of Incinerator emissions needed says Assembly Member.

Thu 15th Mar 2007:

Decision on nurses' pay needs to be revisited says Assembly Member.

Fri 9th Mar 2007:

Assembly Government is delaying new school at Pen-y-Fai says Assembly Member.

Tue 27th Feb 2007:

Benefits from £430m redundancy cost for civil servants are vague says Assembly Member.

Fri 23rd Feb 2007:

Warnings on criminal checks in schools were not heeded says Assembly Member.

Fri 16th Feb 2007:

Assembly Member asks Minister to intervene to preserve funding for Swansea charity.

Thu 8th Feb 2007:

E-Passport flaws highlight ID concerns says Assembly Member.

Tue 6th Feb 2007:

Alley-gating is key weapon in fight against anti-social behaviour says Assembly Member.

Mon 5th Feb 2007:

Staggering insolvency figures highlight debt crisis says Assembly Member.

Sun 4th Feb 2007:

Assembly Member expresses concerns about Quarry dump plans.

Wed 24th Jan 2007:

Complex benefit system at breaking point says Assembly Member.

Fri 12th Jan 2007:

We would all be safer with 500 extra Police Community Support Officers on our streets says Assembly Member.

Bridgend trailing in European funding stakes says Assembly Member.

Wed 10th Jan 2007:

Assembly Member welcomes burns and plastics investment.

Tue 2nd Jan 2007:

Assembly Member hits out at rail fare rises.

Sun 10th Dec 2006:

Labour's double whammy on Post Offices will hit Wales hard says Assembly Member.

Fri 8th Dec 2006:

Devolved pay for teachers a mistake says Assembly Member.

Wed 6th Dec 2006:

Assembly Member attacks new energy price hike.

Thu 30th Nov 2006:

CSA debt write-off is immoral says Assembly Member.

Wed 29th Nov 2006:

Assembly Member welcomes burns research funding.

First Minister should apologise for his government's failure on school buildings says Assembly Member.

Tue 28th Nov 2006:

Assembly Member joins battle over Royal Fern.

Wed 22nd Nov 2006:

Neath Port Talbot Parking policy needs amending says Assembly Member.

Tue 21st Nov 2006:

'No to Blasting' decision at Trebanos is commonsense says Assembly Member.

Fri 17th Nov 2006:

'No win, no fee' compensation claims have hidden costs says Assembly Member.

Thu 16th Nov 2006:

Labour letting down on civil service jobs Wales says Assembly Member.

Tue 14th Nov 2006:

Council tax debt figures 'prove the case for change' says Assembly Member.

Mon 23rd Oct 2006:

Clear assurances needed over Corus pension fund says Assembly Member.

Thu 19th Oct 2006:

Assembly Member congratulates Bridgend schools.

Assembly Member congratulates Swansea schools.

Sun 8th Oct 2006:

Assembly Member joins opposition to merger of children's burns ward.

Wed 4th Oct 2006:

Assembly Member seeks assurances on future of Visteon.

Sun 24th Sep 2006:

Assembly Member joins fight to save local Police Stations.

Mon 14th Aug 2006:

More effective Sex Education needed says Assembly Member.

Mon 7th Aug 2006:

Banks must put responsibilities before profits says Assembly Member.

Wed 26th Jul 2006:

Assembly Member formally objects to Neurosurgery proposals.

Sat 22nd Jul 2006:

Assembly Government should get behind lagoon plan says AM.

Wed 14th Dec 2005:

Scarweather wind farm is not dead and buried yet, warns Assembly Member.

Printed and hosted by Prater Raines Ltd, 82b Sandgate High Street, Folkestone CT20 3BX.
Published and promoted by Peter Black AM and South Wales West Liberal Democrats, Peter Black AM, First Floor, 70 Mansel Street, Swansea, SA1 5TN.
The views expressed are those of the party, not of the service provider.